EU court adviser Maciej Szpunar proposed on November 3 that chatbot answers can infringe press-publisher rights when they recognizably reuse articles’ protected expression. His nonbinding Advocate General’s opinion in Like Company draws a boundary between reporting information and reproducing expression so extensively that readers no longer need the source.

The dispute concerns Hungarian publisher Like Company’s challenge to Google Ireland over Gemini’s use of its articles, according to Anadolu Agency. The Court of Justice of the European Union’s release describes an assessment that includes unlawful access, including circumvention of effective technical restrictions. It also identifies potential liability where infringing use is inherent in the business model or credible, effective safeguards are absent. That puts the proposed test beyond a simple question of whether an answer mentions the same facts. The distinction is how protected expression is reused, not merely whether a chatbot discusses the reporting.

For small publishers, the commercial concern is audience acquisition. Reuters reports that AI summaries may replace search results containing media links, but lost referrals aren’t, by themselves, proof of infringement.

The practical inference for an owner running a small publishing team is to separate traffic effects from evidence of recognizable reuse. An answer that substitutes for a visit may threaten the publisher’s route to readers; that commercial effect and the proposed legal test aren’t interchangeable. As the Law Society Gazette explains, the opinion concerns press-publisher rights, not a blanket rule for every small-business website.

The limits also run backward into model training. Szpunar rejected the training questions as inadmissible because evidence that Gemini had trained on these articles was absent, the Gazette reports. The Court will issue its judgment later; no date is stated, and no final infringement ruling has been established. The structural distinction remains between an answer that competes for attention and one that reuses protected expression.

Sources

Sources