Gemini’s live reuse of news articles risks infringing publishers’ rights, Maciej Szpunar, Advocate General of the European Union, said on November 3, 2026. His nonbinding opinion separates retrieving articles for answers from training models: the issue isn’t simply what an AI learned, but what its answers reproduce.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) case record identifies Case C-250/25 as Like Company v Google Ireland Limited. The Budapest Regional Court referred the questions, Anadolu Agency reports. According to the Law Society Gazette, Like Company alleges repeated reproduction of its articles from June 13, 2023, to May 31, 2024.
The Court’s press release says Szpunar considered training questions hypothetical because evidence didn’t establish that Like Company’s articles trained Gemini; the Gazette reports he declared those questions inadmissible. The release describes training on protected works as generally permitted under the text-and-data-mining exception. For reuse, it identifies unlawful access, including bypassing paywalls or anti-scraping measures, and recognizable reproduction that makes accessing the original unnecessary. Reuters reports Szpunar’s distinction between protection for “only the specific form of expression” and “mere facts”.
A Google spokesperson said, according to Reuters, that Gemini generates original outputs rather than replicating content, and that publisher controls let rightsholders opt out.
Anadolu Agency reports that Szpunar identified possible infringement of publishers’ right to make content available to the public where recognizable reproduction occurs systematically. Providers could face liability when those practices are inherent in their business models or they fail to implement appropriate preventive measures.
Practical inference: small-team owners using news-based AI answers should check access restrictions, reused wording and whether answers substitute for source visits. For small publishers, those checks could inform audience protection and licensing assessments if the Court adopts this approach.
This isn’t a ruling against Google. The Court will issue its judgment later, on an unspecified date. The structural question is whether an answer directs attention to a publisher or makes that visit unnecessary.
Sources
- CJEU press release on the Like Company opinion
- CJEU case record, C-250/25
- Reuters: Google chatbot and publishers’ rights
- Law Society Gazette: Chatbots and press rights
- Anadolu Agency: Gemini copyright opinion
